4 comments 4.9.11

Canadian vs. Hong Kong beggars

Posted by Miss Fong - Filed under , ,
During my trip home recently, I was heckled by a few Canadian beggars and I couldn't help but notice the differences between them and the ones here in Hong Kong.

While Hong Kong beggars get loads of pity points for missing limbs, charred skin or self-mutilation tactics, I hardly ever see anyone stopping to give them money, let alone a second glance. 

On the other hand, Canadian beggars seem to be quite good at getting us to notice them and emptying our pockets. Wondering why this was the case, I came up with three things that Hong Kong beggars could learn from the Canadians to up their daily income: 

1) Be friendly
So I was walking by a liquor store in downtown one night, and a beggar standing outside saw me shivering and asked, "Aww, are you cold?!" I didn't dare answer him nor make eye contact since a) he was a stranger and b) it was late at night, but as I quickened my pace to get away from him, he shouted after me, "Oh well, Happy Monday!!" 

Of course, I felt horrible for running away from such a "nice guy" and it's not only him -- it's exactly the same when you come across squeegee boys at a stoplight and tell them that you don't want your freakin' windshields washed (by a dirty bum like you), only to be told, "Alright, no worries, have a nice day!" So even if you don't end up giving them any money right then, you're more likely to do so the next time you encounter a bum thanks to the cumulative guilt trip you've built up. 

2) Be apologetic

While typical beggars hold up selfish signs like "Please Give" or "Help Me I'm Broke," the ones I saw in Canada amused me with their honest and apologetic messages. Case in point -- one beggar held up the following sign:

Genius, isn't it?! By adding the "I am sorry," the person passing by goes from thinking, 'Go get a job, you selfish bum' to 'Oh well, since you're sorry, I guess it's not your fault, here's some change, ya poor thing'.

3) Be honest, kind of, not really

Lastly, I came across another beggar in downtown who was just sitting on his a wad of newspaper outside of a 7-11. Next to him was a suitcase with a cane sticking out of it, and he was busy doing Soduku or crosswords (or whatever it was, he was completely enthralled with it.)

In front of him, a little tent card read, "Facing eviction. If you CHOOSE to give ... thank you. NOT for drugs or alcohol." That was enough to get me to give him a toonie ($2), since it's the least I could do to help keep a fellow Canadian off the streets.

OK, so whether he was telling the truth or not isn't really the point. The point is that his sign worked, so maybe the real lesson here is -- Hong Kong beggars should use signs...and instead of begging for money using the shock factor, they should just write down what they want from us, like:

  • "1 Big Mac, Not for pimp"
  • "Need bowl of ramen, I am sorry"
  • "I want BBQ pork, Have a nice day"

With signs like these, how could anyone (with a heart) say no?

Blog Widget by LinkWithin


thedeadcockroach said...

The Canadians uses emotional blackmail? lol

Joyce Lau said...

In HK, it's generally known (or at least assumed) that beggars are placed there by triads, and that by giving to them, you're feeding into a system where criminal rings round up the most terribly disabled they can find and dump them on sidewalks.

In Canada, I guess they're more like free agents. But I generally don't give to them either.

I remember the punk kids begging on the streets in Montreal and TO in the 90s, with their Manic Panic hair, Doc Martens, silver piercings and leather jackets. As an aspiring indie-rock kid myself, I knew full well how much that all cost, and the fact that all that change went to fashion, shows, booze and drugs.

Ocassionally, there would be a really sad case -- like some polite old guy who looked really down and out on a cold winter night. But even then I'd rather give food than cash. I'd go get some take-out for him. I knew one guy -- a lawyer in TO -- who'd hand out food like bananas.

But in any case, I think it's better to save your change, and then give generously to a proper charity, food bank or soup kitchen.

Miss Fong said...

Hi Joyce,

I hope you don't take my posts too seriously, of course it's not fair to compare lazy bums in Canada to people who've been trapped and horrifically mutilated to beg for someone else's gain.

I too have never given a Hong Kong beggar anything because it will all go to his pimp anyway, who's probably keeping a close watch on him. Honestly it breaks my heart every time I pass a beggar and I don't know what I can do to help.

I'll try to dig deeper and share what I find, if anything...

Nina Grace said...

I hope no one takes offense to this but, LOL!! Miss Fong your suggestions of signs at the end of your post are funny :) I live in Florida and we too have "beggers" holding different signs. What gets me is that, of all the guys I know only ONE of them has nice hand-writing/penmanship, but all of the male beggers who hold signs up have PERFECT penmanship! Hmmmm..? I do feel bad for those begging, but I can't help everyone. I do help those that I can.